Enzo v2.1 documentation

Auto adjusting refine region

Problem

In nested grid simulations, massive particles from outside the finest nested initial grid can migrate into the refine region. This may cause artifical collapses in halos whose potential is dominated by one or more massive particle. To avoid this in the past, the refine region was set to the Lagrangian volume of the halos of interest at the final redshift.

Solution

On every top-level timestep, we can search for these massive particles inside the current refine region and adjust the refine region to exclude these particles. The covering volume of the highest resolution particles may have been sheared and have an arbitrary shape. We adjust the refine region to have faces just inside of the innermost, relative to the center of the refine region, massive particles. Below is an illustration of this new region.

optimal refine region with particles

Here is the logic that we have taken to adjust the refine region because it is not a trivial min/max of the positions of the massive particles. If we were to take the maximum distance of the highest resolution particles from the refine region center, we would obtain a minimum covering volume that contains all high resolution particles, which is not desired. We will incrementally shrink the region by a cell width on the level with the finest nested initial grid.

  1. Find the mass of the highest resolution particle, Mmin.

  2. Create a list of any particles with a mass > Mmin inside the current refine region. This list is unique on each processor.

  3. Because we will incrementally reduce the refine region by cell widths, it is convenient to convert the massive particle positions to integers in units of these cell widths.

  4. Loop while any massive particles are contained in the refine region.

  5. Originally the code looped over each face of the refine region to search for massive particles, but we found that this favored the first faces (x-dimension) in the loop. So we have randomized which face we will evaluate.

  6. Search for any particles existing in the outermost slab (1 cell deep on the whole face) on the region face in question. If any massive particles exist in this slab, reduce the refine region by one cell width, e.g. -dy on the right face of the y-dimension.

  7. Obtain the min/max of the left/right faces of the refine region from all processors.

  8. Every 6 face loops, check if we have removed any particles (communication required).

    If we haven’t and there still exists massive particles inside the region, there must be particles farther inside (greater than a cell width from the refine region boundary), we must reduce the refine region on a face to search for these particles. This is where the randomization comes into play, so we don’t favor the x-faces. This could be improved by making an educated guess on which face to move inwards by searching for particles near the boundary. However, this might be difficult and time-consuming.

Below in the attachments (region.mov) is an animation showing the above process.